Loading blog content, please wait...
Can You Send Custom Picks Back if Only One Fits? You ordered a set of custom picks, tried them all on, and only one actually worked. Now you're staring ...
You ordered a set of custom picks, tried them all on, and only one actually worked. Now you're staring at a pile of clothes wondering if you're stuck with them. Here's exactly how returns work when just some of your outfit lands, so you know before you order.
You keep what fits and return the rest. That's it. Getting a batch of custom picks doesn't mean it's all-or-nothing. If we send you four pieces and only one earns a spot in your closet, the other three go back and you're only paying for the keeper.
This is the part people worry about the most, and it's the part I want to clear up first. Custom styling is not a mystery box you're forced to accept. It's a starting point. We hand-pick things we think will work for you based on what you told us, but you're the one who gets the final say once they're on your body in your own bathroom light. One fit out of the group is completely normal, especially on a first order when we're still learning your preferences.
Here's something I tell clients all the time: the first custom order is a conversation, not a test you pass or fail. If only one piece works, that's still useful. It tells us the neckline you reached for, the length that felt right, the fabric you didn't want to take off. That's real information we use to make the next round sharper.
Say we sent a wrap dress, a pair of wide-leg pants, a linen top, and a cardigan. You keep the pants and send the other three back. Now we know: you liked the higher waist, the trouser fit worked, but maybe the dress was too clingy and the top ran short. Next time, fewer misses. The one thing that fit isn't the whole win. What you learned about the misses is where the real value is.
So no, one keeper doesn't mean we got it wrong. It means we got started.
Send back the pieces that didn't fit within the return window, in the condition you got them, with tags on. That's the whole ask. You're not filling out a survey or defending your choices. If the pants stay and everything else goes, you package up the rest and ship it back.
A few practical things worth knowing:
If anything about your specific return window or the process is unclear, that's what we're here for. A quick message gets you a straight answer, no runaround.
Fit isn't just whether it zips. This is where a lot of moms talk themselves into keeping something that's going to live in a drawer forever. Before you decide a piece is a keeper, run it through a couple of honest checks.
Does it fit the life you actually live, not the life you wish you had time for? A gorgeous blouse that needs ironing after every wash is a return if you're not an ironing person. Be honest about that. Can you move in it? Bend down for a car seat, reach up for a top shelf, sit through a meeting without adjusting. If a piece only works when you're standing perfectly still, it doesn't work.
And sizing is real, not vanity. Fabrics behave differently, so the same number can fit differently across pieces, which is exactly why we're upfront about how each item runs. If something feels off, trust that feeling. The FTC's guidance on clothing care labels is a good reminder that fabric content and care instructions are on the tag for a reason, and reading them before you commit saves you from a shrunken favorite down the road.
Here's the mindset shift that helps: the goal was never to keep everything. The goal was to find pieces that earn their place. If one dress out of the group becomes the thing you reach for on the days you have no time to think, that order did its job. You'd rather send three things back than keep three things you'll never wear out of guilt.
We built custom picks around the idea that you own fewer, better things. Sending back what doesn't fit is not a hassle we tolerate. It's how the whole system is supposed to work. Every return teaches us your body, your taste, your real week. The client who sends back most of her first order and keeps one perfect pair of pants often ends up with the sharpest custom picks by round three, because she was honest every step of the way.
You can make that first fit-rate higher by being specific up front. If you already know you run wide in the shoulders, hate anything cropped, or live in flats, say so. The more we know going in, the fewer returns you're packing up later.
But even with all that, some things won't fit, and that's fine. Keep the winner. Send the rest back. Let us learn from it. That's the deal, and it's a good one.